Uchungechunge lwethelevishini oludumile olukhiqizwe futhi lwasakazwa isiteshi se-TV esisebenzisana ne-Gülen lugcwale ukugxekwa ngokuxhashazwa kwalo uMprofethi uMuhammad ukuze kuzuze lona.
I-Gülen Movement isebenzisa ngokusobala inkulumo yezenkolo ukuze izivikele ngokunqwabelana okuqhubekayo kwengcindezi njengoba kuvezwa ukurekhodwa okuyimpikiswano eyengeziwe kanye nezinhlelo eziyimpikiswano eziboniswa kumabonakude. Isigcawu esisesiqephu sakamuva se-“Şefkat Tepe” (Hill of Compassion), uchungechunge lwe-TV olusakazwa ku-Samanyolu TV (STV) sashaqisa ababukeli futhi sathukuthelisa abaningi.
Phambilini le nhlangano ike yagxekwa kakhulu ngamakhasethi okuhlanganisa nezingxoxo phakathi kuka-Fetullah Gülen, umholi wale nhlangano nabalandeli bakhe. Kwelinye lala makhasethi, ingxoxo phakathi kuka-Mustafa Günay, unobhala jikelele weNhlangano Yosomabhizinisi Nosozimboni baseTurkey (TUSKON) kanye no-Fethullah Gülen ihlanganisa izihloko eziningi. UGülen uphakamisa ukuthi amalungu ephalamende ashiye eqenjini le-AK. Embhalweni oqoshiwe wangoNovemba 22, 2013, umlandeli wale nhlangano ubalula ukuthi waphupha ngoMprofethi, owamtshela ukuthi aphindaphinde isibalo sama-tweet - aphikisana nohulumeni. UGülen uyaqinisekisa futhi uthi abalandeli bakhe kufanele benze noma yini uMprofethi abatshele ukuba bayenze.
Ngakolunye uhlangothi idlanzana labafundi liphumele obala lavuma ukuthi lanikezwa ukhiye wezimpendulo zemibuzo ezivivinyweni zokungena enyuvesi. Baphinde batshelwa ukuthi u-Fethullah Gülen kuthiwa "uyaphupha" izimpendulo.
Okubaluleke nakakhulu, i-STV yasakaza isigcawu esiyimpikiswano esacasula futhi sadumaza abaningi. Esiqeshini sakamuva salolu chungechunge, isosha elingaphansi kwegumbi labagula kakhulu liphupha lihlangene nozakwabo beqembu futhi licula igama lomprofethi Muhammad. UMprofethi uvezwa njengokukhanya kwehla esibhakabhakeni kwehlela esihlalweni sobukhosi esibekwe ngemuva elolini. Iloli libe selisuka lapho isosha nabangane balo bejaha iloli ukuze liyimise. Isosha lishayiswe iloli lalimala. Isilonda sakhe selashwa ngokukhanya, bese siyanyamalala.
Lesi sigameko sathola ukuhlehla okukhulu okuvela kubantu abambalwa, okuhlanganisa no-Ahmet Tezcan, owayengumbhali weskripthi wolunye uchungechunge lwe-TV esiteshini waze wabona isigameko. UTezcan waphatheka kabi lapho ebona ukuthi uMprofethi obusisiwe uxhashazwa ngale ndlela, esho esitatimendeni sabezindaba. Ngenxa yalokho, umemezele ukuthi uyasula esikhundleni sakhe njengombhali we-script kwa-STV.
Ngakolunye uhlangothi, engxoxweni no-Sabah English u-Eda Tezcan, naye ongumbhali wescript, wasigxeka lesi sigameko ngokungafaneleki ngezindinganiso zenkolo kanye nokuba sezingeni eliphansi ngokwezindinganiso zobuchwepheshe: “Angizange ngikuthole ngempela lokho ababezama ukukusho. chaza lapha… Kunezinto ezithile ongakwazi ukuzibalekela ungazifaki embhalweni futhi lokhu bekungesinye salezo zigcawu,” kusho yena. U-Tezcan unqume ukuthi lesi sigameko singaba umlayezo ovela ku-Fethullah Gülen, ophila ekudingisweni okuzenzela yena, oya kubabukeli ukuze badlulisele umbono wokuthi bawumphakathi okwazi ukuzuza noma yini ngomthandazo. Ngaphezu kwalokho, u-Tezcan waveza ukuthi umProfethi angeke ehliswe isithunzi sokuba ngundabamlonyeni ochungechungeni lwe-TV, olufana nolohlelo lwezingane lwangaphambili, “u-Selena” – inganekwane – lapho iqembu lezingane lihlangana khona limbize lapho lidinga usizo.
Wachaza ukuthi izigcawu ezinjalo azigcini nje ngokungenangqondo kodwa futhi ziphazamisa umphakathi nezindinganiso zethu ezingcwele ezifanayo. U-Tezcan ubize lesi sigameko ngokuthi "asinangqondo futhi asihloniphi" futhi wathi angaba namahloni ukubhala lesi sigameko uma ecelwa ukuba enze kanjalo.
Ocingweni oluya ku-fatwa yoMnyango Wezenkolo waseTurkey - ozinikele ekuphenduleni imibuzo emayelana nezinqumo zamaSulumane kunoma yini kusukela ezindabeni zansuku zonke kuya ezindabeni ezinzima kakhulu - i-Daily Sabah yabuza ukuthi isigameko siyahambisana yini nezimiso zamaSulumane. Isazi sakuqinisekisa ukuthi akulungile ukuhlanganisa uMprofethi nezimfanelo ezingaphezu komuntu nokuthi ungumuntu ozalwa ngumama njenganoma yimuphi omunye umuntu. Uqhube wathi le ndawo okukhulunywa ngayo ayiyona into eqanjiwe futhi akumele ihunyushwe ngokuthi iyiqiniso. Ngaphezu kwalokho, wabuye waphawula ukuthi ukunakekelwa okukhulu kufanele kuthathwe lapho kuchazwa amaphupho e-Islam. Amaphupho angeke athathwe njengezambulo zaphezulu njengoba ezithoba kakhulu ekuqondeni komuntu ngamunye ngakho-ke abantu akufanele basekele izimpilo zabo eduze kwabo.
Izazi eziningi nazo zasigxeka lesi sigameko ngokuthi asifaneleki futhi siyadukisa. UYusuf Şevki Yavuz, uprofesa we-Islamic Theology e-Istanbul's Marmara University uzwakalise ukudumala kwakhe ngalesi sigameko futhi wasigxeka ngokudukisa umphakathi: “IKur'an ibiza umProfethi ngokuthi 'ukukhanya,' kodwa lokhu kuyincazelo engokomoya futhi akufanele. kungasuswa engqikithini njengoba kwenzeka lapha.” Uveze ukuthi ngokweziqondiso zamaSulumane, bekungeke kulunge ukudweba isithombe somProfethi esingajwayelekile kanjalo nesingenangqondo. UMnu. Yavuz uphinde waveza ukuthi akufanelekile ukuxhaphaza umProfethi ngokumsebenzisa njengethuluzi lokuzivikela ezindabeni zezwe: “Esikhathini esidlule, labo ababephila impilo yobungcwele babengasoze badalula okuhlangenwe nakho kwabo ngokomoya futhi kuwukuziphatha okubi ukusebenzisa abantu abangcwele abanjalo ukuze bavikele inhlangano yezenhlalo noma yezombangazwe.” Ngakolunye uhlangothi, u-Servet Bayındır ovela ku-Faculty of Religion e-Istanbul University waphawula, "Akukho okunye engingakusho ngaphandle kokuthi lesi sigameko asinasisekelo enkolweni yamaSulumane." UVehbi Vakkasoğlu, naye oyisazi, uthe uMprofethi ngesinye sezihloko ezibucayi kakhulu kumaSulumane, ngoba uwudumo lwe-Islam: “Kungiphatha kabi kakhulu ukumbona esetshenziswa ngezindlela ezingahunyushwa kabi abantu abaningi. .”
Ngaphezu kwalokho, uDkt. Mustafa Öztürk wathi wayebheka lesi sigameko njengokuxhashazwa komProfethi futhi sasingelutho ngaphandle kokuthola inkolelo-ze. UDkt. Hüseyin Hatemi naye usigxekile lesi sigameko futhi wathi ngokwezindinganiso zendawo, kungaba yinto evamile ukulindela ukuthi umProfethi aye endlini kaGülen ePennsylvania futhi wakhiqizwa ngamabomu ukuze enze abantu bakholwe izimo zabo.
Kokubili i-STV nabakhiqizi nababhali balolu chungechunge benqabile ukuphawula ngale ndaba.
Iziphathimandla zamaSulumane zithi izithombe zezinto eziphilayo kanye nezidalwa azivunyelwe futhi azithandwa. Okubaluleke nakakhulu, i-Islam ikwenqabela ngokuqinile ukuveza izithombe noma imifanekiso yoMprofethi, othathwa njengesidalwa esikhulu kunazo zonke sikaNkulunkulu, kanye nesibonelo esiphelele sesintu, esingenakuvezwa ngemisebenzi ebonakalayo.
